Skip to content
C.W.K.
Stream
Lesson 01 of 05 · published

Accepted Is Not Decided

~11 min · acceptance, decision, state, verdict

Level 0Cold Iron
0 XP0/36 lessons0/12 achievements
0/100 XP to next level100 XP to go0% complete

Accepted Is Not Decided

In an Open Run judge response, accepted: true means exactly one thing: that judge's structured ballot passed validation and was stored. It does not accept a candidate, identify a winner, close the bench, or authorize Dad's verdict.

The engine can emit bench_complete only after every currently mobilized judge has ruled. Even then it waits. Because the Open Run bench is unbound and Dad may add another judge, only Dad's explicit POST /decide closes and totals the board.

That action creates decided. It still does not publish, deploy, merge, or alter a canonical repository. Dad then reviews the board and takes the verdict action, which records acceptance or dissent and finalizes the Anvil record.

Precise verbs preserve authority: ballot accepted, bench complete, board decided, run finalized, external work landed, and product deployed are different facts with different proof.

accepted: true acknowledges a ballot, not an artifact. Never promote a transport receipt into a verdict.

Code

Four boundaries — mixing the verbs leaks authority·python
STEPS = [
    ("ballot_stored",   "one ballot is stored"),
    ("bench_complete",  "every live judge has ruled"),
    ("decided",         "Dad closed and tallied the board"),
    ("finalized",       "the verdict finalized and revealed the record"),
    ("landed",          "it actually landed in the outside repository"),
]


def what_is_true(reached):
    i = [k for k, _ in STEPS].index(reached)
    return {
        "true": [d for _, d in STEPS[:i + 1]],
        "not_yet": [d for _, d in STEPS[i + 1:]],
    }


now = what_is_true("ballot_stored")
assert len(now["true"]) == 1 and len(now["not_yet"]) == 4
print("true at accepted:true →", now["true"])
print("not yet →", now["not_yet"])

# Even finalized is not shipped — the last step is always outside Anvil.
assert "it actually landed in the outside repository" in \
    what_is_true("finalized")["not_yet"]

External links

Exercise

For a four-judge Open Run, state what is true after the second ballot, fourth ballot, Dad's decide call, and Dad's verdict.
Hint
Keep ballot receipt, bench completion, board decision, and finalization separate.

Progress

Progress is local-only — sign in to sync across devices.
Spotted a bug or have feedback on this page?Report an Issue

Comments 0

🔔 Reply notifications (sign in)
Sign inPlease sign in to comment.

No comments yet — be the first.